Guide

What to do if you can no longer keep your pet

This is a hard place to be, and you are not alone in it. There are more options than surrendering to a shelter, and some are easier on your pet.

Updated November 18, 2026. 4 minute read.

Key points

  • First check whether the problem can be solved. Many can, with help.
  • If you adopted, read your contract. Many rescues require the pet to come back to them.
  • Rehoming directly, from your home to the next, spares your pet a shelter stay.
  • Never abandon a pet. It is dangerous for the animal and can be a crime.

An ASPCA study published in 2015 estimated that more than one million households rehome a pet each year. The most common main reasons were problems related to the pet (46 percent), family situations (27 percent) and housing issues (18 percent). Rehomed pets most often went to a friend or family member (37 percent) or to a shelter (36 percent).

Step 1: See whether the problem can be solved

Humane World for Animals notes that many hardships that come up between an owner and a pet are temporary or can be resolved with help.

  • Cost. Pet food banks, low-cost clinics and payment plans exist. See help keeping your pet.
  • Housing. Some landlords make exceptions, and federal rules protect pets in some kinds of housing. See renting with pets.
  • Behavior. A sudden change can be medical, so start with a veterinarian. If you adopted, call the rescue. Many offer free behavior support.
  • A short-term crisis. A hospital stay, a move or leaving an unsafe home may need temporary care, not a permanent goodbye. The help guide lists programs for that.

Step 2: Go back to where your pet came from

If you adopted, read the adoption contract. Humane World notes that some organizations require in the contract that you return the pet to them if you can no longer provide care. Even when it is not required, the rescue knows your pet and already has adopters asking. Call them first.

If your pet came from a breeder, call the breeder. The ASPCA's criteria for responsible breeding include being able and willing to take back or rehome an animal at any time, for any reason.

Step 3: Rehome your pet yourself

Humane World says your home is usually the best place for your pet while you search for an adopter. Best Friends Animal Society adds that pets who move directly from one home to another skip the stress, health risks and behavioral strain of a shelter stay.

Where to list

  • People you know. Friends, family, coworkers, your veterinarian's bulletin board. This is where rehomed pets most often go.
  • Rehome by Adopt a Pet. A service for rehoming a pet directly from your home to an adopter's. Its page currently describes a small one-time listing fee per pet, so check the cost before you start.
  • Home To Home. A rehoming program of the nonprofit Better Together Animal Alliance that connects pets with people interested in adopting them.
  • Your local shelter's rehoming page. Some shelters now help owners find a new home without taking the pet in. Human Animal Support Services, a project of Austin Pets Alive, calls this supported self-rehoming.

Write an honest profile

Humane World advises sharing any medical or behavior issues your pet has. Include good photos, age, size, habits, what your pet loves and what kind of home would suit them. Honesty protects your pet from being passed along again.

Screen adopters

  • Talk on the phone first. Best Friends recommends this before you introduce anyone to the animal.
  • Ask about their home, other pets, children, work hours and past pets.
  • Meet in person, more than once if you can. Let them meet your pet, and trust your read of how they act together.
  • Ask for a veterinary reference if they have had pets.
  • Send your pet with veterinary records, the microchip number, food, bedding and a written page of habits. Then update the microchip registration to the new owner.

Charge a small rehoming fee

Best Friends explains that a rehoming fee is charged to help offset costs like vaccines or veterinary care. Adopt a Pet encourages a small fee in direct rehoming, and warns that pets offered free are less likely to come with medical history, vaccinations, spay or neuter surgery or behavior information.

Step 4: If you must surrender to a shelter

The ASPCA advises that, where possible, relinquishing a pet to a shelter should be a last resort. If it comes to that:

  • Call ahead. Humane World notes that each agency has a different process and says to check its website or call. Adopt a Pet reports that some facilities do not allow walk-in surrenders and almost all charge a fee.
  • Expect an appointment. Some shelters use managed intake. Best Friends describes it as scheduling owner surrenders so that a one-on-one conversation can happen. You may be offered help that lets you keep your pet.
  • Bring everything. Veterinary records, medications, and an honest history: bites, fears, habits, what works. Staff can only place your pet well if they know the truth.
  • Ask questions. How long do animals usually wait? What happens if my pet is not adopted? Can I be told the outcome?

You can find shelters and rescues in your state to compare options. A breed rescue or a rescue for senior pets may be another option. Ask whether they have space.

What not to do

  • Do not abandon your pet. Leaving a pet outdoors, in an empty home or at a closed shelter's door puts the animal in danger, and it can be a crime. In California, for example, willfully abandoning an animal is a misdemeanor. Oregon also treats animal abandonment as a misdemeanor.
  • Do not hand your pet to a stranger the same day. Take the time to screen.
  • Do not hide problems. A bite history or a medical condition that is left out will come back on your pet.

Be kind to yourself

Finding a good new home for a pet you cannot keep is a responsible act. Take the time to do it carefully, and let yourself grieve it.

Sources

Facts and figures in this guide come from these pages. Check them for the latest details.

  1. ASPCA. New study spotlights need to help people keep their pets. December 2015.
  2. Humane World for Animals. Need to find your pet a new home?. Viewed November 2026.
  3. ASPCA. Position statement on criteria for responsible breeding. Viewed November 2026.
  4. Best Friends Animal Society. Rehome pets without going through shelters. Viewed November 2026.
  5. Best Friends Animal Society. Rehoming a pet: finding a good new home. Viewed November 2026.
  6. Adopt a Pet. Rehome. Viewed November 2026.
  7. Home To Home. About. Viewed November 2026.
  8. Human Animal Support Services. Home page. Viewed November 2026.
  9. Adopt a Pet. Free pets. June 2026.
  10. ASPCA. New York City frequently asked questions. Viewed November 2026.
  11. Adopt a Pet. How do I surrender my dog?. July 2025.
  12. Best Friends Animal Society. Setting the record straight on managed intake. Viewed November 2026.
  13. Michigan State University Animal Legal and Historical Center. California Penal Code 597s: abandonment of animals. Checked August 2026.
  14. Michigan State University Animal Legal and Historical Center. Oregon consolidated cruelty statutes. Viewed November 2026.

This guide is general information gathered from the sources above. It is not veterinary or legal advice. For your own pet's health, talk to a veterinarian.